| YEAR | PLAYER. | ORGANIZER/PLAYER. |
| 2011 | . | . |
| 2010 | NO ELECTION | . |
| 2009 | BILL STRONG | . |
| 2008 | NO ELECTION | . |
| 2007 | . | .JIM HALLIGAN |
| 2006 | . | CHRIS SURPRENANT |
| 2006 | . | .SHAWN CASTLEBERRY |
| 2005 | DAVE LICK | . |
| 2004 | JIM PAGLIARULO | . |
| 2003 | CATHY HANSEN | . |
| 2002 | . | ALFONSE ALBA |
| 2001 | . | GEORGE WOOSTER |
| 2000 | . | DON BECK |
| 1999 | CLIFF COSTELLO | . |
| 1998 | . | .TOM MONAGAN |
| 1997 | . | .CHARLIE DONOFRIO |
| 1996 | . | DON MAINE |
| 1996 | . | BILL CHOSER |
| 1996 | . | DENNIS HANSEN |
| 1995 | . | GILL LEE |
| 1995 | . | DWIGHT HANSEN |
| 1995 | . | PETE BOCHESE |
| 1995 | . | ED MANCINI |
| 1994 | WALT BAGLEY | JOE FESTA |
| 1994 | WES KING | AL LATOUCHE |
| 1993 | JOHN DUDEK | GEORGE TRABUCCHI |
| 1993 | RALPH HILLBURN | . |
| 1993 | DOM MAJIEWSKI | . |
| 1992 | GUIDO GIORGETTI | WALT MROZEK |
| 1992 | BILL DOYLE | ROGER HANSON |
| 1992 | DWIGHT SMITH | . |
| 1992 | SHERMAN GREEN | . |
| 1992 | WILLIE PARADIS | . |
| 1991 | NORM RIOUX | SAM BARTRAM |
| 1991 | DON WEIK | LESTER LANE |
| 1991 | BILL CROFUT | FRANK WAGNER |
| 1991 | . | DON HARRISON |
| 1991 | . | MICKY VECCHITTO |
| 1991 | . | ERVIN VANDINE |
| . | . | . |
| /////////////// | ////////////////////////////////////////////////////// | /////////////////////////////////////////////////////// |